Janeen Martin: When Faith Heals—and When it Hurts
Religion and Mental Health
This week, Tim and Aubrey had a fascinating conversation with therapist and researcher Janeen Martin about the complex and deeply personal ways that religion and mental health intersect.
Janeen has spent years working with clients navigating the full spectrum of religious experience—some who find their faith to be a source of deep resilience and healing, and others for whom it has been a source of pain and struggle. That contrast led her to ask some big questions: What makes religion a protective factor for some and a source of distress for others? How do individual personality, family dynamics, and church culture shape the way we engage with faith? And most importantly, how can we cultivate a relationship with God and our faith that supports our mental and emotional well-being?
One of the most interesting ideas we explored was the concept of attachment styles—how the way we relate to God often mirrors the way we’ve experienced relationships with authority figures in our lives. Janeen also introduced us to three different religious orientations—extrinsic, intrinsic, and quest—and how our approach to faith can evolve over time. We talked about how religious communities can create spaces for both conviction and curiosity, how parents can help their kids develop a healthy and secure faith, and how we can each pay attention to the signs that our relationship with God is either building us up or weighing us down.
This conversation was rich with insight and practical tools for anyone wanting to engage with their faith in a way that is both deeply meaningful and emotionally healthy. We hope you find it as valuable as we did.
And if you enjoyed this conversation, check out
STUDY “COME FOLLOW ME” WITH FAITH MATTERS
To receive Come Follow Me resource roundups from Faith Matters in your inbox, first be sure you are subscribed to the Faith Matters Substack, then go to manage your subscription and turn on notifications for “Come Follow Me”.
COMING UP AT THE COMPASS
How do we come to terms with the existence and relevance of gold plates in the restoration story? Join Terryl Givens and Rosalynde Welch of the Maxwell Institute, as we continue exploring The Big Questions.
Friends of Faith Matters and paid Substack subscribers get complimentary access to livestreams and recordings of Faith Matters Compass events—a link will be emailed to you 24 hours before the event. Thank you for your support!
Our Compass events are subsidized and made possible by private rentals of the space for wedding receptions, business retreats, birthday parties, and more. If you or someone you know has an event coming up, consider supporting Faith Matters by recommending The Compass!
VIDEO: JONATHAN RAUCH AND TERRYL GIVENS
THIS WEEK IN WAYFARE
